If your drivers keep leaving, the first place to look is not the sign-on bonus. It is the paycheck and the calendar. Truck driver retention comes down to two questions drivers ask every week: Do I know what I will earn? and Will I be home when I was told I would be? Carriers that answer both clearly keep drivers longer, and every seat that stays filled saves you the cost of recruiting a replacement.
What the latest driver survey says
The Fall 2025 truck driver survey from Conversion Interactive Agency and People. Data. Analytics is a useful reality check. Among drivers looking for a new job, about 58% named better home time as a reason, about 52% named predictable compensation, and about 43% named consistent miles. Roughly a quarter said they felt disrespected by their current employer. The same survey found that over 61% of drivers would accept lower pay in exchange for more time at home, and that 56.3% of drivers were actively job hunting, the highest share in four years of tracking.
Read that last number as a warning: more than half of the drivers on the road are open to a better offer, including yours. The survey did not publish its sample size, so treat the percentages as directional rather than exact. The direction is still clear.
Make pay predictable before you make it bigger
Many fleet owners respond to turnover by raising the per-mile rate. That helps, but a higher rate with an unpredictable settlement still loses drivers. A driver who cannot estimate Friday's check cannot plan rent, child support or a truck payment, and that is a faster path to the door than a rate that is two cents lower.
- Publish the pay math. Give every driver a one-page sheet showing the rate, how miles are calculated (practical vs. hub), and every deduction and bonus.
- Explain every settlement line. A short note on anything unusual prevents the angry call to your office.
- Set a minimum for slow weeks. A modest weekly guarantee for new drivers during their first 90 days takes the fear out of a bad dispatch week.
- Pay on time, every time. Late or corrected settlements damage trust more than almost anything else you control.
Treat home time as a promise, not a perk
Home time matters because it is a commitment you make in the interview. Drivers rarely quit over a stated policy of three weeks out and four days home. They quit when "four days" becomes two, or when the date moves a second time.
- Write the policy down in plain numbers: weeks out, days home, and what happens if a load runs late.
- Plan the home-time load first. Dispatch should build the route back to the driver's home area at the start of the trip, not on Thursday.
- Track promises kept. Measure how often a driver actually gets home on the committed date. If the number is below 90%, you have found your retention problem.
- Offer options when you can. Since a majority of surveyed drivers would trade some pay for time at home, a regional or dedicated lane with a slightly lower weekly gross may be the best retention tool you own.
Consistent miles and honest communication
Drivers on per-mile pay are paid for turning wheels, so a truck that sits waiting for a load is a pay cut. Look at which drivers have the lowest weekly miles and ask why. Is it a bad lane, a slow dispatcher, or a customer with long detention? Fix the cause, and if detention is the cause, pay it.
Then address respect, the quietest reason on the list. A driver who gets a call back within a few hours, a dispatcher who knows their name, and a direct answer when plans change will tolerate more than one who feels like a unit number. Set a response-time target for your dispatch and safety teams and review it monthly.
Ask before they leave
Most carriers learn why a driver left only from the exit paperwork. Instead, call every driver at day 14, day 45 and day 90 with three questions: Is your pay what you expected? Are you getting home when promised? Is there anything about dispatch or equipment I should fix? Write down the answers. Within two or three months you will see the same two or three issues repeating, and you will know exactly where to spend money.
A simple retention scorecard
Review these numbers every month, by driver manager or dispatcher:
- Percentage of home-time commitments met
- Average weekly miles per truck and the spread between best and worst
- Percentage of settlements issued on time and without corrections
- Number of drivers lost in their first 90 days, and the stated reason
Key takeaways
- Pay predictability and home time are the leading reasons drivers say they are looking elsewhere.
- Over half of drivers in the fall 2025 survey were actively searching, so your drivers are being recruited right now.
- Write down your pay math and home-time policy, then measure how often you keep them.
- Check in with new drivers at day 14, 45 and 90 and act on what you hear.
When your team runs out of hours
Retention work and recruiting compete for the same few hours of your week. If your team is stretched, handing the sourcing, screening and orientation scheduling to an outside recruiter lets you spend your time on the part only you can do: keeping the drivers you already have.
Need CDL-A Drivers? We Recruit Them for You.
CDL Transportation Group finds, qualifies, and delivers CDL-A OTR company drivers all the way to your orientation. No retainers, no setup fees, and no ad spend on you — you pay $2,000 per seated driver, split into two $1,000 payments, backed by a replacement guarantee.
Tell us how many drivers you need →
CDL Transportation Group | CDL-A OTR Driver Recruiting
