Most fleets are setting 2027 budgets right now, and the driver line is the one most likely to be wrong. A truck driver hiring plan built on last year's turnover and last year's pay assumes a labor market that no longer exists. Here is what the current data says, and a simple way to turn it into a seat-by-seat hiring number for your fleet.
Why 2027 hiring will look different from 2025
Through 2025, soft freight kept drivers in their seats. That is changing on the supply side, not the demand side. FreightWaves reported in October that the SONAR Truckload Rejection Index held near 14%, about three times its 2023-2025 range, while truckload volume rose only 9% over three years. The same analysis lists three forces shrinking the compliant driver pool: 202,345 CDL and permit holders in prohibited status in the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse as of January 2, 2026, a non-domiciled CDL rule that could affect up to 194,000 drivers over time, and English-proficiency enforcement taking about 2,700 drivers out of service per month. FreightWaves expects the market to stay tight through early 2027.
The National Transportation Institute's Q4 2026 outlook puts numbers on the people side: the for-hire driver population fell more than 5% in 2025 and another 1% in early 2026, and some fleets have moved solo OTR starting pay into the 70-cent-per-mile range. Carriers feel it. In the FreightWaves Q3 2026 Carrier Rate Report, 73.07% of surveyed carriers expected recruiting to get harder over the next six months, up from 53.34% the prior quarter, and none expected it to get easier. At the same time, 55.76% planned to add trucks in the next 12 months. More carriers chasing a smaller pool is the core planning problem for 2027.
Step 1: Count the seats you actually need to fill
Your annual hiring need has three parts, and most budgets only include the first:
- Replacement hires = trucks × your annualized turnover rate. If you don't track it, ATRI's Operational Costs of Trucking: 2026 Update reports an industry average of 44.2% for 2025, down from 48.0% in 2024. Treat that drop as a soft-market effect, not a new normal: ATRI attributes it to drivers being less willing to switch jobs when fewer positions were open.
- Currently empty seats. ATRI found 10% of carriers' trucks were unseated in 2025, up from 7% a year earlier. Count yours honestly, including trucks you parked "temporarily".
- Growth seats for any trucks or lanes you plan to add.
Worked example (assumed numbers): a 30-truck fleet with turnover at the ATRI average (44%), 3 trucks parked today, and plans to add 3 trucks in 2027. Replacement hires: 30 × 0.44 ≈ 13. Total seats to fill: 13 + 3 + 3 = 19 drivers in 2027, or roughly 1.6 per month. Many owners of a fleet that size would guess "five or six." That gap is why trucks sit.
Step 2: Work backward through your hiring funnel
Nineteen seated drivers is the output. To plan the input, you need your own conversion rates from the last 6-12 months: leads to qualified applicants, qualified applicants to orientation, orientation to still-employed at 30 days. If you have never measured these, start now and use conservative placeholders until you have real data.
Assumed funnel for illustration only: if 1 in 4 leads is qualified, 1 in 3 qualified applicants reaches orientation, and 85% of orientation attendees are still driving at 30 days, each seated driver takes about 14 leads. Nineteen seats means roughly 270 leads across the year, or about 22 a month. Replace every ratio with your own numbers; the point is to know how many leads you need per month so you notice early when you fall behind.
NTI's outlook adds a caution: the safest experienced drivers are usually already employed, so fleets fishing only where active job seekers look are competing with everyone else for the same small group. Expect each lead to cost more and plan for referrals and relationship-building with passive candidates, not just more job-board spend.
Step 3: Price pay into the plan, not after it
ATRI puts 2025 industry-average driver wages at $0.818 per mile and benefits at $0.210, the first year combined driver compensation passed one dollar per mile. Those are 2025 numbers, and NTI says pay moved significantly in Q3 2026. Budget against what competitors in your lanes pay now, not against last year's survey.
ATRI's data also gives you a way to weigh a raise against hiring cost: on average, each additional $5,000 in annual driver pay was associated with a 2.9-percentage-point lower turnover rate. In the 30-truck example, 2.9 points of turnover is less than one driver per year (30 × 0.029 ≈ 0.9). That is a modest effect on its own, so pay changes work best combined with the retention fixes below rather than as the only lever. ATRI notes wide fleet-to-fleet variation, so treat it as a direction, not a guarantee.
Step 4: Cut the replacement number, not just fill it
Every point of turnover you remove shrinks the hiring target. ATRI found that each extra 30 minutes of average dwell time per stop was associated with a 5.4-point higher turnover rate, which means detention is a retention problem as much as a billing problem. Practical moves for 2027:
- Review your worst facilities by dwell time and reprice, rebook or drop the chronic offenders.
- Track turnover separately for drivers in their first 90 days; that is where the losses concentrate for many fleets.
- Make settlements predictable. NTI points to renewed interest in pay guarantees for new hires while they learn your operation.
- Keep equipment and home-time promises measurable, and check them monthly.
Step 5: Build the calendar and the capacity to execute it
A hiring plan needs owners and dates. Set a monthly target for leads, orientations and seated drivers. Front-load Q1 if you lose drivers over the holidays. Decide who on your team makes first contact with new leads and how fast, and who runs Clearinghouse, MVR and PSP checks so a qualified driver is not waiting a week for an orientation date. Rate forecasts support planning for a tight year: C.H. Robinson's October 2026 update keeps its dry van cost-per-mile forecast at +30% for 2026 and +10% for 2027, and notes that federal enforcement on CDLs, visas and English proficiency is expected to shrink the driver pool further. If your rates rise, some of that margin needs to fund recruiting and retention, or the trucks will not be staffed to haul the freight.
Key takeaways
- Driver supply is shrinking while 55.76% of surveyed carriers plan to add trucks, so 2027 hiring will be more competitive than 2025.
- Calculate hiring need as replacements + empty seats + growth; at average turnover, a 30-truck fleet may need around 19 hires (assumed example).
- Convert seats into a monthly lead target using your own funnel ratios.
- Budget pay at today's market, not last year's averages.
- Lowering turnover and dwell time reduces how many drivers you have to find.
Planning is the easy part
Writing the plan takes an afternoon. Hitting 20-plus leads a month, calling each one back quickly and getting qualified drivers to orientation takes daily work. If your team doesn't have the time to keep that pipeline full all year, outsourcing part of your recruiting can be the most practical way to stay on target.
Photo: Carlos ZGZ, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Need CDL-A Drivers? We Recruit Them for You.
CDL Transportation Group finds, qualifies, and delivers CDL-A OTR company drivers all the way to your orientation. No retainers, no setup fees, and no ad spend on you — you pay $2,000 per seated driver, split into two $1,000 payments, backed by a replacement guarantee.
Tell us how many drivers you need →
CDL Transportation Group | CDL-A OTR Driver Recruiting
.jpg){kind=link}